Urbanization effects on shoreline phytobenthos: a multiscale approach at lake extent

To understand how littoral biota respond to anthropogenic disturbances, limnologists seek to detect the scale at which patterns and processes occur. We conducted an extensive study on the shoreline phytobenthos of Lake Garda (Italy) with the following main objectives: (i) to examine the importance of urbanization for species distribution within a set of hierarchical spatial scales (101– 104 m), and then (ii) to test the spatio-temporal interactions on a reduced set of scales (101–102 m, and 101–102 days). Results showed that most of the variation in most abundant species and habitat characteristics occurred at the spatial scale of 101–102 m. Species richness was positively related with microheterogeneity, but the relationship occurred only at low urbanization and not at highly-urbanized sites where artificial shores were less heterogeneous. The similarity of species assemblages was regulated by two interacting processes, one operating at a fine spatial scale (102 m), reflecting the physical-habitat requirements of the species, and the other one operating at a broader scale (104 m) in relation to the N–S nitrogen gradient. Overall, time explained 73 % of the total variation of species assemblages, space 7 %, and 20 % was explained by the interaction between space and time (the patch scale, 10s of m, and area scale, 100s of m, interacted with the finest temporal scale, 10s of days). This interaction might be explained by the process of species recruitment operating at different rates at the two spatial scales. Since the largest variation in species assemblages was at the temporal scale (due to the seasonal succession of phytobenthos), we recommend collecting at least one sample per season when monitoring littoral habitats.